top of page
  • Instagram
  • TikTok
  • Facebook
  • YouTube

A Simple Scoop, a Complex Craft

1 hour ago
7 min read

LOST IN TRANSLATION: LIFE OF A JAPANESE GIRL IN ITALY


In Italy, my favourite gelaterias are all closing for their winter break at the end of November. I won't see them again until next summer. Reluctant to say goodbye, I'm making the most of these final days.


I enjoyed my latest gelato on a solitary autumn evening walk
I enjoyed my latest gelato on a solitary autumn evening walk

How many times did I eat gelato this summer? It was perfect as an after-school treat on hot days, or as an excuse to invite someone I wanted to get to know better for a little chat. Gelato was easy to buy and fun to compare from one gelateria to another, and I went so often that I could almost call it an addiction.


As I tried more gelato, I began to notice differences even within the same flavour. Take hazelnut, for example. At one shop, the roasted aroma stood out; at another, the nutty flavour filled my mouth; elsewhere, the milk was more prominent. The textures varied too. Some melted away smoothly, others lingered with a rich, dense consistency, while some had a slightly icy texture. I enjoyed discovering these differences, but I didn’t really understand what caused them.


Some gelaterias were hugely popular, while others attracted less attention. As a customer, I could clearly taste the differences, but where did they come from?


Curious, I began looking into it. I discovered that far more decisions had gone into each scoop I had enjoyed so casually than I had imagined.


The Science of a Smooth Texture

What makes gelato delicious is a combination of factors: ingredient quality, balance recipe, equipment performance, and temperature control. Compared with conventional ice cream, gelato generally contains less air and is often served at a slightly higher temperature. This gives it a dense yet soft texture. However smoothness and the way it melts in the mouth depend on more than just air and temperature. The size of the ice crystals and the balance of water, sugar and milk fat also shape how it feels when we eat it.


What's Inside Gelato?

What first fascinated me was that not everything in gelato is frozen. Milk-based gelato contains tiny ice crystals, fat droplets, air bubbles, and unfrozen liquid with dissolved sugars.  Even when two gelaterias use the same pistachios, variations in their recipes and freezing methods can produce very different textures. Making gelato means considering not only an ingredient’s flavour, but the texture through which it is experienced.



Sugar has a role beyond adding sweetness. It lowers the temperature at which water begins to freeze, helping to control how soft the gelato remains when served. Reducing sugar to make a less sweet gelato also changes its firmness. Different sugars vary in both sweetness and their ability to prevent freezing, so gelato makers combine them to achieve the desired sweetness while keeping the gelato soft enough to scoop.


Dairy ingredients do more than add fat. Milk also contains water, proteins and lactose.  Choosing whether to use cream, add mascarpone or supplement milk solids with skimmed milk powder affects the flavour and texture differently. Adding pistachios or chocolate introduces further considerations, as their fat and other components also affect how the recipe is balanced.


In my research, I discovered that the word 'base' can mean several things. It may refer to the milk mixture prepared in a gelateria, or to a ready-made mix produced by a manufacturer, combining sugars, milk components, stabilisers and other ingredients. Some commercial bases are designed to be added in small quantities, while others provide an almost complete recipe. Hearing that a gelateria 'uses a base' tells us little about its ingredients or how much the gelato maker adjusts the recipe.


The decisions don’t end once the recipe is ready. What machine should be used? How quickly should the mixture be frozen, and how much air should be incorporated? Next come storage and serving. If the temperature fluctuates during storage, ice crystals can grow larger, sometimes giving the gelato a grainy texture. Even with excellent ingredients, careful production and temperature control are essential to preserve their qualities until the moment we eat it.


What Does ‘100% Natural’ Really Mean?

I remember visiting L’Angolo del Gusto in Vercelli. The seasonal flavours we sampled tasted so intensely of their ingredients that my friend and I ended up ordering four flavours each for the first time in our lives.


 Pumpkin, chestnut, persimmon and amarena cherry ripple gelato
 Pumpkin, chestnut, persimmon and amarena cherry ripple gelato

At that moment, a poster reading ‘100% Natural’ caught my eye. The gelateria chooses organic and local ingredients wherever possible, with an emphasis on seasonality. Its milk and cream come from mountain farms in Piedmont. The hazelnuts are IGP-certified from Alta Langa and roasted in a wood-fired oven. With a few exceptions, the nuts are made into pastes in-house. When frozen tropical fruits are used, this is clearly indicated.


Looking through their ingredient list, I noticed that milk-based flavours contained locust bean gum and guar gum. This made me stop and think about the word ‘natural’. Perhaps I had unconsciously taken it to mean ‘nothing added’.

Both locust bean gum and guar gum are stabilisers derived from plant seeds. They help prevent ice crystals from growing larger during storage, preserving the texture. Depending on the type, quantity and recipe, however, they can also increase viscosity and thickness. Too much may leave the gelato feeling heavy in the mouth.


Emulsifiers serve a different purpose. They act on the surface of fat droplets, helping the fat partially come together during churning and form a structure that supports air bubbles. Stabilisers and emulsifiers both affect texture, but they do different jobs. I began to realise that the ingredients I had previously grouped as ‘additives’ each had a distinct purpose.


Colourings are used to restore or intensify the appearance of food. In tourist areas, some gelaterias display enormous mounds of gelato in astonishingly bright colours, accompanied by flavour signs that look almost AI-generated. As we have grown more accustomed to life in Italy, these shops have become less tempting. Some of the best gelaterias, in fact, serve gelato in rather muted colours.


Does ‘natural’ refer to where ingredients come from? Does it mean avoiding synthetic flavourings and colourings? Or does it mean making gelato from raw ingredients in-house?


I would like to ask the owner of L’Angolo del Gusto what the word means to them. Because they make their ingredients public, I feel the conversation can move beyond ‘What goes into it?’ to ‘Why do you choose to use it?’


The Craft and Skill of Choosing Not to Use


In contrast, at Sablé in Bologna, owner Alessandro Cesari explains that he doesn’t use thickeners, emulsifiers or stabilisers. What caught my attention was how this approach relates to the way he runs his gelateria. According to Gambero Rosso, gelato is made once a day, with no extra batches kept in reserve. When it sells out, the shop closes.


The decision to use stabilisers to maintain texture during storage is also linked to how soon the gelato is intended to be eaten. Sablé made me realise that a recipe doesn’t begin and end in the kitchen. What to add, how much to make and when to serve it are all connected. Together, these choices shape each scoop of gelato.


So I can’t simply say that gelato tastes better because it contains no stabilisers, or that plant-derived stabilisers have no effect on texture. What kind of texture is the maker trying to achieve? How do they balance the ingredients and deliver the finished gelato? Each maker has their own approach.


At the same time, I admire the skill involved in achieving a desired texture without relying on stabilisers. The choice not to use them relies on careful adjustments to the recipe and by the way the gelateria produces and sells its gelato each day. Understanding the work behind that decision makes even a single spoonful taste different.


What Does a Gelato Artisan Actually Do?

As I visit gelaterias across Italy, I often come across the word artigianale. It refers to something made by hand or through artisanal production, though at first, I had little sense of what that work actually involved.


Now, I realise much of it lies in judging ingredients, constantly learning, and investing time and money to refine the craft.


Which milk should they choose? How far should they roast the nuts? If they grow herbs in ƒtheir garden, when should they pick them, and how should they extract the aromas? When the sweetness or water content of fruit changes, how should they adjust the recipe?

From a Slow Food perspective, I also want to understand what happens before the ingredients reach the gelateria. How are the animals raised on the farms that supply the milk? Who is preserving the varieties of fruit they use? Under what conditions are cocoa and vanilla produced before travelling from distant countries? And how much of the processing does the gelateria do itself?


Alongside the decision of what not to add, a gelateria's philosophy is reflected in what it chooses to use and whom it buys from. The more I learn, the more I am surprised by how much thought goes into making gelato.


Investment in machinery and equipment also helps turn that knowledge and judgement into something tangible. Through experimenting, tasting and adjusting: this process of research continues in everyday production.


The more I learn about speciality coffee or bean-to-bar chocolate, the more I notice how origin, roasting and processing shape the final taste. Gelato turned out to be much the same. Behind a flavour labelled 'pistachio' are the ingredients themselves and the work of the people who handle them.


The possibilities for expression are expanding, too. A classmate told me about MINIMAL in Taichung, Taiwan, which became the world's first ice cream establishment to receive a Michelin star in 2024. Its seasonal tasting menus incorporate ice cream, granita and other frozen creations, using temperature and texture to shape each course.


From a scoop enjoyed on the way home from school to a tasting menu savoured at a table, makers can take many different approaches to the same frozen dessert.


This summer, I ate spoonful after spoonful, saying, ‘This is delicious’. I enjoyed those moments perfectly well without knowing much about what went into making the gelato, and I’m sure I will continue to do so.


But the next time I discover a flavour I particularly love, I would like to ask a little more.


Why did you choose this ingredient?

How did you create this texture?



Follow our journey @movimento.metropolitano


bottom of page